Gary McGath


About Gary McGath

I am a freelance technical writer in Plaistow, NH.

25 years ago: September 11, 2001   Recently updated !

25 years ago, I drove to work in Woburn, Mass. When I got to the building, a crowd was gathered around a TV. All I could immediately gather was that Bush was saying something of great concern, and people were too distracted to explain it to me. After going up to the office I learned what had happened.

I had a window that looked east, and normally I regularly saw planes taking off from Logan Airport. The absence of flights for the next few days made the most direct impact on me. MASSFILC published a songbook, which I edited, in memory of the thousands of deaths.

Another kind of harm took longer to emerge, and it’s played out to the present. Congress passed the “temporary” Patriot Act, which is still in effect today. The TSA made life miserable for air passengers without being effective at catching threats. Congress created the Department of Homeland Security and ICE. A bus was stopped in mid-trip in New Hampshire, and passengers were given the choice of allowing a warrantless search of their luggage or being abandoned far from any bus station. The US government used lies to justify an invasion of Iraq. Warrantless domestic surveillance greatly increased. None of this did much to make us safer.

American society’s distrust of foreigners, especially Muslim foreigners, increased. Every president since 2001, including one who got a Nobel Peace Prize, has launched military actions in the Mideast. Trump has hit new levels of audacity, but Congress has long been in the habit of shrugging off presidential usurpations of the war-making power. “National security” has become the all-purpose excuse for power grabs.

The World Trade Center was only the most visible part of the damage which Bin Laden did. The effects on our society have been far more persistent.


SUBSCRIBE

Enter your email address to subscribe and get notifications of new posts by email.


ICE watching in New Hampshire   Recently updated !

For the second Tuesday in a row, I hung around a polling location with a clip-on camera, in case the Feds tried anything. Except for an ambulance taking someone away, presumably because of a medical issue and not violence, nothing out of the ordinary happened. I got noticed, though.

The amusing thing was a guy standing outside with a Scott Brown sign. Brown was one of the two leading candidates for the Republican Senate nomination; he lost to John Sununu. Sununu has Trump’s endorsement, but Brown is as bad. Sununu supports the SAVE Bill and wants the government to ignore the Constitution’s birthright citizenship clause. I barely looked at the sign holder, but every time I walked by, he tried to talk with me. I don’t know what he was thinking; his comments were just weak attempts at conversation starting. He must have noticed the camera, though, and I’m hoping that he was nervous because of that. At one point he suggested I pick up a Goodlander sign that was lying on the ground, though I’d shown no sign of partisan preference; Goodlander has won respect for standing up to Trump’s call for her execution.

That’s not much. One guy with a camera maybe making one Trumpist worry that if ICE goons showed up, they could be caught on camera. But if lots of people are watching the polls in November, it could make ICE less inclined to intimidate people. And if it still does, there will be more video records of its action.

It’s not much, but it’s something.


SUBSCRIBE

Enter your email address to subscribe and get notifications of new posts by email.


Publicizing those worth publicizing   Recently updated !

Many people on social media put their efforts into pointing out ridiculous or nasty statements. Sometimes denunciation is necessary, but it shouldn’t be anyone’s main focus. It gives publicity to bad ideas. When a lot of people do it, it makes them part of the dominant dialogue. It draws attention away from people with more reasonable and better argued positions. Some people will find the nonsense interesting and even convincing.

Focusing on people with good things to say and solid arguments behind them draws attention to them, and usually that’s helpful. People can learn something from them, which is more than they can do from the words of fools.

I’m not saying that “Any publicity is good publicity” is literally true. There have been plenty of cases where people have said unpopular things and suffered a loss of business and reputation. But repeatedly hearing an idea can make it seem more acceptable. Anyone who already felt sympathy for it might feel less marginalized.

People need to rally around good ideas more than they need to denounce bad ones. If they only hear that bad ideas are bad, they’ll become discouraged or cynical. Without good ones, you don’t even have a standard that lets you reject the bad ones. Tyranny is bad because freedom is good. Socialism is bad because individual autonomy is good. Murder is bad because human life is good. Bad ideas can be worth dissecting, but you need a framework to do it.

As George Washington may or may not have said, let’s raise a standard to which the wise and honest can repair.

Note: I accidentally published a fragmentary draft on freedom of expression in Bow, NH. I immediately deleted it, so probably only the people who get email notifications saw it. Sorry.


SUBSCRIBE

Enter your email address to subscribe and get notifications of new posts by email.


A note on my novels   Recently updated !

Because of changes to the terms on Draft2Digital, which acquired Smashwords, my e-books are no longer available there. I’m looking for alternatives and will let you know when they’re available again. Amazon should be unaffected.


SUBSCRIBE

Enter your email address to subscribe and get notifications of new posts by email.


ICE watching in Haverhill   Recently updated !

Donald Trump has refused to rule out sending ICE agents to the polls, even though sending armed federal agents to a polling place is illegal. They wouldn’t have to do anything beyond being there to intimidate voters, and their presence in well-chosen places could influence an election’s outcome.

We can discourage it by making sure there are observers at high-risk locations to record them if they show up. Big Brother, knowing he’s the one being watched, may be more reluctant to follow through. Knowing this, on September 1 I went to the City Hall in Haverhill, Mass., a polling place for the state primary. It’s less likely ICE would interfere with the primary, but it’s good practice and establishes my commitment for November. Next week I have similar plans for the New Hampshire primary, though I haven’t decided where. I chose the Haverhill location because a valued friend was working at the polls there.

Entrance to voting at Haverhill, MA City HallIt was boring work, which is a good thing. It was also miserable weather. Part way through the morning, I had to go home and change into dry socks. I was standing intermittently for four hours, which says I’m in better shape than I thought. Forgetting that ultraviolet doesn’t care about clouds, I got a slight sunburn on my ear.

Did I accomplish anything? I made a few people aware someone was standing by with a camera in case anything nasty happened. While I was there, I had a friendly conversation with the cop who was stationed there and told some of the poll workers what I was doing; my friend probably explained further when I wasn’t there. I went outside and got some exercise. On top of that, for a few hours I was pushing back against the intimidation of Americans.

It was worth it. It will be worth it again next week, even if it’s as boring as I hope it will be.


SUBSCRIBE

Enter your email address to subscribe and get notifications of new posts by email.