As I’ve discussed in past posts, some convention codes of conduct have blanket bans on “derogatory” statements. Here’s one I came upon recently, from a university rather than a convention. As reported by FIRE, the institution put a professor “on paid leave and banished her from campus for 15 months for ‘unprofessional’ speech and making students ‘uncomfortable.'” On top of that, “the university also ordered her to undergo professional-development training in workplace communication, conflict resolution, and ‘behavioral sensitivity.’”
Typical “woke” behavior by a university, coming down on a faculty member who has dared question some part of the left-wing orthodoxy? In this case, no. Pepperdine University put Christina Littlefield on leave for saying harsh things about her colleagues and teaching from a book that some parents found objectionable. The book was American Jesus, by Stephen Prothero.
A Pepperdine spokesperson has denied that her teaching had anything to do with the university’s actions: “While the University does not comment on individual personnel matters, it categorically denies that it has taken any disciplinary action against Dr. Littlefield for her classroom teachings or for exercising her freedom in scholarly engagement, research, or publication.” However, it has also told her that “your conduct in the classroom has made students feel uncomfortable.” Students should feel uncomfortable some of the time. It’s part of learning new things.
It may not be surprising that a university that aggressively emphasizes its Christian nature isn’t very tolerant. The point I’m making here, though, is that it has adopted language often used by people with seriously different views to justify its actions. Standards of conduct that condemn derogatory statements as such and prohibit making people uncomfortable are usually associated with organizations that boast of their openness and diversity. They apply the rules selectively, in ways favoring the organizers’ views. They make such rules appear legitimate, and they and their friends aren’t the only ones who notice.
Littlefield’s web page on the Pepperdine site mentions that her “former investigative work as a reporter for the Las Vegas Sun led to the indictment, conviction and jail time of a community college vice president who was using college materials, equipment and employees to build his ranch estate.” I’m sure that made some people uncomfortable. It doesn’t mention anything about her mandatory leave.
Open debate isn’t always pleasant and comfortable. It’s still necessary if people are going to challenge orthodoxies, whatever kind they might be.