Book Discussion: The Grim Old Days   Recently updated !


Many people think life was simpler and easier in the days of low technology. People lived simple, easy lives on the farm, in harmony with nature. Well, actually … life was very rough in those days. Unbelievably rough, if all you know about is today’s comforts. Chelsea Follett’s The Grim Old Days tears up those notions, showing what life was really like without machines, scientific medicine, freedom of thought, and plumbing.

A word of warning, though. If you’re easily “triggered,” you may want to skip the book. Follett writes about some really gruesome aspects of pre-industrial life.

Cover of The Grim Old DaysSome of the information in the book is widely known, but much of what it tells us will shock the average reader (and shocked me). Most people know, or should know, that in Europe before modern medicine, children had a poor chance of reaching adulthood, women had many children in the hope that some would survive, and men often killed each other in recurring wars. Sanitation was horrible. Rivers were simultaneously sewers and sources of drinking water. Alcohol was often safer, but it meant people were always at least a little drunk. That included children. Privacy hardly existed in one-room homes.

Royalty and nobility fared better, but even the way kings lived was squalor by modern standards. In the 17th century, the Palace of Versailles “lacked bathrooms, leading to human waste accumulating in every hallway, corner, and courtyard.” Queen Elizabeth I suffered from decay in multiple teeth, and extraction was a nightmare.

The way people dealt with diseases is, pardon the expression, sickening. It’s hard to imagine why people thought feces and urine had medical value. They were desperate enough to try anything, I suppose. These people weren’t any less intelligent than we are today; scientific, evidence-based testing just wasn’t in their mental toolkit. All they had to go by was the claims they heard.

The book is powerful, but I’d have liked to see more hard data. A skeptic might note that a collection of stories, which the book basically is, can select its material to give almost any impression the author wants. It covers many centuries, and while it’s mostly about Europe, it has material on the rest of the world. More systematic information on life expectancy, disease, other causes of death, and so on would have made its case more convincing. Hard numbers generally aren’t available from the Middle Ages, but an approach that didn’t jump around as much would make it easier to draw comparisons. More context would have been helpful as well; I recognized some of the events cited as occurring during the Thirty Years’ War, which was a terrible time even by early modern standards.

The Grim Old Days doesn’t have much about life in North America before the Europeans arrived. This may be because not much information is available. The people living north of the Rio Grande mostly didn’t have written records, and the smallpox epidemic that followed the first European landings seriously disrupted the cultures. Americans seem to have a Hiawatha-like fantasy about how they lived, one with nature and ruled by the law of peace. But it’s hard to imagine they didn’t have epidemics, periods of famine, and violent encounters. They certainly weren’t strangers to warfare, even if they lacked firearms.

The book provides a good overview of what people had to endure before technology started to make life easier. It’s an antidote to the romanticization of ye olde days. But don’t read it just before dinner.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *